Senate Parliamentary Expert Says Pence ‘Has No Authority’ To Thwart Biden’s Election
Reprinted with permission from American Independent
Alan Frumin, who served under both Republicans and Democrats as parliamentarian of the Senate, agreed on Tuesday that the course of action that Donald Trump has been pressuring Mike Pence to take during the election certification amounts to a "coup."
Frumin appeared on CNN with Anderson Cooper, who recapped Trump's request that Pence disrupt or delay the Electoral College certification so Trump would be declared the winner instead of the real winner, President-elect Joe Biden.
"Essentially, that's a coup. That's a coup attempt, is it not?" asked Cooper. "If this happened in some, you know, developing country where the person who lost the election just announces that they didn't lose the election, I mean, that's a coup."
"I will not disagree with that characterization," Frumin replied.
Frumin also noted that despite claims from Trump and others, Pence does not have the power to undo the certification of the vote and Biden's win.
Frumin served as Senate parliamentarian from 1987 to 1995 and again from 2001 to 2012. In that role, he advised the elected leaders of the Senate on the body's rules and procedures to keep them in compliance.
Frumin is also the editor of Riddick's Senate Procedure, which is a compilation of Senate precedents.
From the Jan. 5 edition of CNN's Election Day in America:
ANDERSON COOPER, CNN: What play does the vice president have if he wanted to try to do something in favor of President Trump?
ALAN FRUMIN: Well there are two parts of that question: What can he do physically and what can he do legally? Legally, he opens ballots and he announces the result. Beyond that he has no authority to do anything.
Having said that, what can he do if he simply decides to announce and pronounce that he and Donald Trump have won the election? Well, we would be in crazy town, then. A place where we've never been. Should that happen, it would seem to me that the two houses are not without recourse.
In each, the House and the Senate, whenever the presiding officer makes a ruling, those rulings are always subject to appeal in the respective houses. And an appeal the question on an appeal is challenge the decision of the chair stand as the judgement of either the Senate or the House.
And so, the burden would be on the chair, in this case the vice-president, to have both houses of Congress separately vote to sustain whatever it is he was pronouncing, so —
COOPER: Essentially, that's a coup. That's a coup attempt, is it not? I mean, if this happened in some, you know, developing country where the person who lost the election just announces that they didn't lose the election, I mean, that's a coup.
FRUMIN: I will not disagree with that characterization.
Published with permission of The American Independent Foundation.
- Trump Calling Supporters To Capitol For 'Wild Time' When Electoral ... ›
- Pence Quietly Seeking To Salvage Reputation As Trump Implodes ... ›
- Trump Claims Georgia Runoff is 'Illegal' and 'Invalid' On Twitter ... ›
- Supreme Court Unanimously Rejects Trump Effort To Overturn ... ›
- Pence Quietly Seeking To Salvage Reputation As Trump Implodes ... ›
- Wall Street Journal Editorial Rebukes Trump For 'Embarrassing ... ›
- Why Pence Won't Be Able To Block Congressional Confirmation Of ... ›
- #EndorseThis: Colbert Unveils ‘The Adventures Of Mike Pence’ - National Memo ›
- Congress Certifies Biden Victory --But Democrats Denounce GOP 'Co-Conspirators In Sedition' - National Memo ›
- #EndorseThis: Colbert Spoofs Exiled Pence For 'Couch-Surfing' In Indiana - National Memo ›
- Trump hopes Pence 'comes through' to overturn election; VP has no ... ›
- US election: Legal bid to get Pence to overturn results rejected ... ›
- Fact check: Can U.S. Vice-President Mike Pence, Republicans ... ›
- Donald Trump asked Mike Pence to overturn the election. Can he? ›
- Pence Seeks to Dismiss Lawsuit to Overturn Election Results | Time ›
- Pence Welcomes Futile Bid by GOP Lawmakers to Overturn Election ›
- Biden election: Mike Pence 'welcomes' senators' bid to derail result ... ›
- Fact check: No, Pence can't overturn the election results ›
- Can Pence overturn the 2020 election? - CNNPolitics ›