Experts Roast Trump’s ‘Incompetent' Lawsuit Against Social Media Giants
Reprinted with permission from Alternet
Donald Trump, the former president, on Wednesday announced what he described as a class action lawsuit against "Big Tech," specifically Facebook, Twitter, and Google, and their CEOs as well. Trump for about 50 minutes ranted and railed about having been banned from the social media platforms, along with numerous other grievances.
Trump, his team, and the group supporting him, America First Policy Institute, are essentially claiming Trump's First Amendment rights were violated when he was banned from the two social media platforms, and because they have protection under federal law known as Section 230, they are an arm of the government, which experts say is false.
Legal experts are responding negatively to both the lawsuit itself and the attorneys who filed it.
Sam Brunson, Georgia Reithal Professor of Law, Loyola University Chicago, mocks their AOL email addresses and calls them "not competent."
Honestly, I don't know anything about these attorneys except that, based on the first 10 paragraphs of the complaint, they are not competent attorneys.\n\nSee also, AOL websites.pic.twitter.com/FptQFSC7OG— Sam Brunson (@Sam Brunson) 1625671908
He also calls the lawsuit a "LOLsuit."
Commercial, trademark, copyright, patent and trade secret litigation attorney Akiva Cohen calls the attorneys a "clown show."
I'll do a full breakdown later. Briefly, though ... check out the signature block on this clown show https://twitter.com/adamsteinbaugh/status/1412789327751438338\u00a0\u2026pic.twitter.com/vwHrScvjoa— Akiva Cohen (@Akiva Cohen) 1625672936
And also mocks them for having AOL email addresses, among other things.
have profiles highlighting their personal injury and wrongful death work.\n\nThe idea that *these* are the lawyers representing a former President of the United States in a (bullshit) First Amendment litigation is just laughable— Akiva Cohen (@Akiva Cohen) 1625673403
I mean, guys ... John P. Coale is the *retired* lawyer husband of Greta van Susteren. Frank Dudenheffer is a 75 year old New Orleans attorney whose primary practice, per Google, is personal injury, admiralty, & products liability. ROLAND PAUL IS A DAMN TRANSACTIONAL LAWYER— Akiva Cohen (@Akiva Cohen) 1625673875
University of Michigan law professor, NBC News and MSNBC legal analyst, former US Attorney:
\u201cCongress\u201d shall make no law \u2026 Trump and his lawyers need to read the first line of the First Amendment. His lawsuit complaining of censorship against private social media companies and their leaders is going nowhere.https://www.cnbc.com/2021/07/07/trump-says-he-is-suing-facebook-google-twitter-dorsey-zuckerberg-pichai.html\u00a0\u2026— Barb McQuade (@Barb McQuade) 1625675863
Brad Heath, DC reporter for Reuters on crime and justice:
Trump's Twitter lawsuit also is filed in Florida. Twitter's terms of service - which courts generally enforce - require that "all disputes related to these Terms or the Services will be brought solely in the federal or state courts located in San Francisco County."— Brad Heath (@Brad Heath) 1625673677
Preston Byrne, partner at Anderson Kill Law Firm, Fellow at Adam Smith Institute:
The complaint alleges that the 104th Congress passed this law in 1996 with a view to encouraging Facebook, which did not exist, and Zuck, who was 12 years old, to unconstitutionally censor Donald Trump - 24 years in the futurepic.twitter.com/daIT1N5FBq— Preston Byrne (@Preston Byrne) 1625674949