Reprinted with permission from MediaMatters
More Americans are going to die from the novel coronavirus COVID-19 because President Donald Trump is watching Fox News and listening when the network's hosts minimize the risks posed by the deadly epidemic. I can't put it any more plainly than that.
Since 2017, I've reported on how Trump's obsessive watching of Fox turns into hyperaggressive tweets and government policy. This Fox-Trump feedback loop has dictated presidential pardons, federal contracts, and even a partial government shutdown.
It is dangerous to have a highly suggestible president who prefers to listen to a cable network's propagandists rather than experts. The result is a broken policy process where officials are forced to fight the president's television for his attention — even trying to reach him directly by appearing on his favorite shows.
Since I began studying the Fox-Trump feedback loop, I have worried the most about two scenarios where the president's Fox obsession could prove uniquely disastrous: the prospect of a military confrontation with a nuclear power and a global pandemic. As of yet, we've avoided the first. The second is here.
The coronavirus has infected more than 100,000 people in at least 97 countries, with a death toll now approaching 4,000. In the United States, at least 34 states and the District of Columbia have confirmed cases for a total of more than 500 infected people — surely an undercount because there's a lack of available test kits. Thousands are being asked to self-quarantine in the hope of minimizing community spread and preventing a drastic shortfall in hospital beds.
The U.S. was not prepared to respond to the coronavirus — in no small part because Trump had hamstrung the nation's pandemic response capabilities. The Washington Post detailed Saturday the "many preventable missteps and blunders in the federal government's handling of the coronavirus crisis — the embodiment of an administration that, for weeks, repeatedly squandered opportunities to manage and prepare for a global epidemic." The problems started from the top: Trump "has undermined his administration's own efforts to fight the coronavirus outbreak — resisting attempts to plan for worst-case scenarios, overturning a public-health plan upon request from political allies and repeating only the warnings that he chose to hear," Politico reported the same day.
Trump's lax response to the spread of the coronavirus mimics the reaction of his favorite network — and that's no coincidence. The president is shunning aides who provide him with negative information about the epidemic and basking in Fox's glowing coverage. On Friday afternoon, amid a rambling and incoherent press event at the headquarters of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention in Atlanta, Trump downplayed the threat posed by the disease, praised his administration's response, lashed out at Democrats, and told reporters that he was getting information about the spread of the coronavirus from Fox.
"As of the time I left the plane with you, we had 240 cases — that's at least what was on a very fine network known as Fox News," he said. "I know you love it. But that's what I happened to be watching." This was not an anomaly. As coronavirus spread in February 2020, Trump sent more than twice as many live-tweets of Fox's coverage as he did in February 2019. On Friday morning alone, he sent three tweets about coronavirus in response to Fox.
What was Trump learning from his regular Fox-watching? Roughly an hour before his comments, a Fox medical correspondent argued on-air that coronavirus was no more dangerous than the flu; a few hours later, the same correspondent argued that coronavirus fears were being deliberately overblown in hopes of damaging Trump politically. The network's personalities have frequently claimed that the Trump administration has been doing a great job responding to coronavirus, that the fears of the disease are overblown, and that the real problem is Democrats and the media politicizing the epidemic to prevent Trump's reelection. The president absorbs those narratives and parrots them to the public in tweets and statements; the network responds by continuing to push those talking points.
No one wants a public panic. But by downplaying the risks of coronavirus in order to rally to Trump's defense, Fox is endangering its audience, which skews older and is most susceptible to the disease. It seems to be having an effect — both anecdotally and based on polling: Republicans are less likely to view the disease as a serious threat.
But the greater danger is that one of Fox's older Republican viewers is the president of the United States. And when the network tells him that coronavirus is nothing to worry about, he listens.
As a result, a significant number of Americans are likely to die — prematurely and unnecessarily — because Trump is taking advice from Fox News. We are courting disaster, thanks to the Trump-Fox feedback loop.
